I can’t help from still finding humor from Andy Baio’s “The Daily: Indexed.” For those who haven’t seen it, Baio noticed that The Daily — the Murdoch-owned iPad app — had online versions of its stories but no index or table of contents; so he created a hack to index the newspaper. Why was there no table of contents? The Daily wants to be able to eat its cake, in that it wants its walled garden but doesn’t want to lose out on the viral functionality offered by social media tools. The Daily wants its paid users to peruse its articles and then tweet them out within the app, but only within the app. If people were able to easily peruse the table of contents, The Daily’s staff feared, then people wouldn’t pay for the app. The Daily is essentially trying to maintain what has quickly been labeled a “leaky wall” (The New York Times has launched its own leaky wall recently).
Of course by opening leaks in the wall, the hackers find ways to nudge their way in. Baio was one such hacker, Joshua Benton from Harvard’s Nieman Lab was another. The Daily has tried to keep a tight lid on how many people are actually paying for and using the app, but because of the Twitter API, Benton was able to team up with Postrank to measure how many people are actually tweeting within the app, and used the long-term trends to map the downward trajectory of app use.
Meanwhile, Matthew Ingram got his hands on a newly-released social media policy document from the Toronto Star. In it, he found these quotes:
Anything published on social media – whether on Star sites or personal platforms – cannot reveal information about content in development, newsroom issues or Star sources … As well, journalists should refrain from debating issues within the Star’s online comments forum to avoid any suggestion that they may be biased in their reporting.
“The Star is not the only media outlet making these kinds of errors,” Ingram concludes. “While they are happy to use social media to push their content, most major newspapers have failed to take advantage of these tools when it comes to building relationships with their readers.”
I mention all these incidents together — The Daily: Indexed, the Daily Twitter API, the Toronto Star’s social media policy — because they represent a kind of stepping stone in the newspaper world. We keep hearing newspaper executives admit that their companies were “slow to adapt” to the new media environment, but this has always been said in past tense, as if they were slow to adapt but now that they’ve recognized this flaw they’ve turned the ship around. But often we see incidents like the example above, where the newspapers approach these social media tools with the idea that they can somehow fit them into their already-existing media strategy. They aim to keep all the seeds firmly planted in their own garden.
You can follow me on Twitter or go ahead and hire me.